Welcome to Phansite archive (beta)
You'll find here all archived threads from the Phansite forum.
Was math invented... or discovered?
Discuss
Mathematics were simply discovered, then given conventional names. The concept of two, such as your two hands, already existed. We simply gave it a name. These are self-evident in the universe, and thus did not have to be created
Are you sure that mathematics were created by humans to benefit themselves? That math may change due to the situation at hand to make our statements correct? A good example I saw was this: If the earth disappeared, then math would disappear with it. It would be the same with stuff like tennis and chess.
If the earth and all people were to disappear, then mathematics as a class would disappear. However, mathematics as a concept would not. Assuming the rest of the universe still exists, there would still be eight planets orbiting one sun (fuck You scientists Pluto is a planet). Simply because no one is around to observe these facts does not prevent them from existing
Complex arithmetics were invented to torture highschoolers.
If the earth disappeared, then math would disappear with it. It would be the same with stuff like tennis and chess.Math can be applied anywhere and is not limited to earth. Math has a strict set of rules which cannot be changed or bent, that's why I think they were discovered rather than invented. Sure, things like our numeral systems would be lost, but these are replaceable and they don't change how math works in any way.
Right Mishima
Mathematics was invented, though it can be used to describe many phenomena very well, it does not perfectly describe them meaning it does not define the universe but it is our best way to understand reality.
The short answer to this question is yes.
You can edit your messages, Android Guy.
You can edit your messages, Android Guy. I wanted two posts.
(edited by Android_Guy)
You make no sense.
The statement of being able to apply Mathematics anywhere is not really true. You cannot calculate your thoughts or ones psychic nor can you calculate ones emotion. And to the question if Mathematic is an invention or a discovery, it truly is a discovery. The ways of using Maths, stuff like algebra and geometry or trigonometry are an invention of the human.
Everything that was discovered has to have been invented at one point.
And who invented life? God is not an answer as god is but a theory, something that cannot be proven or disproven. Which I think people call parasoxic.
Everything that was discovered has to have been invented at one point. Invention =\= discovery. We discovered fire. Didn't invent it.