Generations

Haven't had a chance to play Mania, but as a whole, I generally prefer the Adventure/Modern Sonic style gameplay, so I'd likely end up choosing Generations anyway.

Mania is fucking good, okay? Generations was good, but Mania... Mania is really fuckin' good.

Mania alllll the way baby

I loved both games, but I think Mania did better than Generations.

https://youtube.com/embed/e7tDXsWYaWI?autoplay=1 I think Forces was Alright. Mania... Hasn't Looked at.... Generations...It was great. That's about it from experience

I love Mania, but Generations is just to close to my heart. Mostly because you had all the others in game, my fav Nostalgia of some of my fav stages came back and well I am actually better at modern than at the old games, even though I love the old games. I didn't like Forces, the only thing I like was Fist Bump and Infinites Theme.

Generations, only cause I have yet to play Mania

Both of those are horrible Sonic games in general. '06 Is where it's at.