Welcome to Phansite archive (beta)
You'll find here all archived threads from the Phansite forum.
Best Navigator
Here is the list of navigators from worst to best.

Fuuka, Morgana, Teddie, Futaba, Mitsuru, Rise.

Rise is still best, any who disagree have shit taste. Also she's got the best abilities in P4G. Fuuka's voice is insufferable so she's worst.
I FUCKING HATE FUUKA!
Fuuka, Teddie, Morgana, Mitsuru, Futaba, Rise
Oops wrong Fuuka, sorry about that.
if anyone says fuuka is best they're just wrong. you're wrong.
How can you say others have bad taste when Teddie isn't dead last? Or at the very least worse than Morgana?
From worst to best:

Teddie, Rise, Mitsuru, Morgana, Fuuka, Futaba.

Fight me.

But if we count this, best navigator of all:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nukx1gSCF4c
See, Kala-Nemi knows what's up.
Teddie is awful, don't get me wrong, but I didn't have to listen to him for nearly as long as I did Fuuka. Also Morgana is shit and sends me to bed every night. Teddie never installed a bedtime on me.
Morgana was eh? What put me off was his constant IT'S SCARY HOW GOOD I AM.
Fuuka isn't bad. Her English voice is... questionable sometimes, but she's way better than Rise.
I hesitate to really count Mitsuru, Teddie and Morgana, but the worst to best for me are...

Teddie, Rise, Morgana, Mitsuru, Fuuka, Futaba.
Okay but Rise is pretty annoying too. Maybe it's my inherit dislike of P4 seeping through, but the only good part about Rise is her skills. (and playing as her in P4AU is admittedly pretty enjoyable)
Yeah and Fuuka is terrible
*gasp* The enemy!
Honestly I don't know why people complain about Fuuka's English voice when Rise's is so much worse.

*SQUEALS* SENPAI THAT WAS SO COOL
Kill me.
Worst to Best:

Fuuka, Teddie, Rise, Morgana, Mitsuru, Fuuka.
I know people are gonna argue if I mention this, but I've never played Golden and would like to point out in the original Persona 4, Teddie and Rise are objectively the worst Navigators, period. They cannot scan for weaknesses like in 3, and the only skills Rise can learn are really basic and not all that useful. She gets like a minor regen and the ability to find treasures? Hoorah?
*re-reads own list* Wait a minute....

Futaba should be the best, not Fuuka.
That's just a problem with P4 in general. Legit, no one will stop sucking Yu's dick for an extended period of time. It gets irritating pretty quickly.
I know Fuuka's English voice was annoying (this is why I just played an undub) but at least she could y'know. Do something.
I didn't like Fuuka or Rise a lot of the time, but at least ALL the navigators have voice lines I can spam..

TAKEBA IS IN DANGER
GASP THE ENEMY
SENPAI THAT WAS AMAZING
I'll agree that Rise was shit (as a navigator) in p4. I found her endearing though, and aesthetically (for me) she's the best girl in that game. Though I don't mind upbeat types, like I know a lot of people do. Fuuka's nav skills were far and away better than vanilla-P4 Rise's, but gods I didn't have the choice to play undubbed, and her voice, her stupid fuzzy hair, and her boring ass social link all drained the life out of me. She always sounds like she was punched in the gut and is speaking in exasperated surprise. p4G Rise though is the bomb.
Rise got better as you raised her Social Link (in terms of skills, not in terms of sucking Yu's dick 24/7) but she still pales compared to the kind of stuff Futaba (and by extension, Makoto) can do in P5.

Heck, Futaba triggers buffs more often than Rise ever did.
fu!! ta!! ba!!
Pure_anon has spoken. It is law.

Jokes aside, my list would look something like this:

Teddie, Mitsuru, Morgana, Rise, Fuuka(by a tiny margin), Futaba / Makoto(They basically do it together)
Futaba!!
Why have you revived this