I've seen the topic pop up, so I figured I'd say my piece on the matter. I can't say I have any experience running a site, but I've seen enough go downhill because of bad mods. This isn't me Saying Inari, or anyone else that was mentioned would make a bad mod, I'm just saying that being one is a big responsibility. The choice comes down to Mishima in the end, but I think we should really consider who would make a good moderator before we go throwing out suggestions.
(I am flattered that I was mentioned though.)