Welcome to Phansite archive (beta)
You'll find here all archived threads from the Phansite forum.
NANAKO DOJIMA P6 MC?
I thought it would be an interesting concept to have an existing character to become an MC, since nanako will be about the right age i presume at this time, and since we don't see her talk to anyone apart from dojima and the scooby gang in too much detail i thought she would make a good MC, what are your thoughts?
Or on any existing character for that matter
OOC: Unlikely, that's not how Persona games work, interesting tho
If the time gap between 5 and 6 is the same as 4 and 5, she'd be of the right age for it.

But I think she more likely comes back in a cameo like Chihiro did in P4.
I have been behind this idea for years

At the least I would like her to be a party member in the future
Unlikely because the Mc has to be a loser with no skill and that's barely interesting
Hey, for all you know, Nanako could totally be a loser with no skill.
Not possible my dude
Personally I'm sorta sick of losers as MC, let's just make em an actual person for once and give up on the whole blank slate idea. Be nice to have a leader who ya know leads.
P5 Mc isn't a blank slate though
No but the game likes to pretend he is sometimes. And he's still a silent protagonist, I wouldn't mind doing away with that TBH.
Why would I want be a somebody when I'm already a nobody
I agree with tasu here
Last blank slate MC was P3's emotionless emo boy.
The most blank slate MC is the P1 protag. Tatsuya and Maya obviously are the most developed, being actual characters in a game. The P3-P5 protags, while pretty blank, do have distinct personality traits that they lean more towards as shown by the dialogue choices they each get. And I guess Q exists so you see what Atlus has the opposite protag do when not the leader.
Click to load png image (size - 209 kb)
souji noooo