Welcome to Phansite archive (beta)
You'll find here all archived threads from the Phansite forum.
[POTENTIAL SPOILERS] For those who have played Persona 2
So not too long ago, I got around to playing P2, which was difficult given the circumstances of one being officially translated on one console, and the other on another. So, I just ended up using a fan translation for Innocent Sin.

What I wanted to ask is this: which of the two parts do you like more? Innocent Sin, or Eternal Punishment? Why? For me, I like Eternal Punishment more. I find the fact that it was the only to break the mold, and not have the main cast be a group of high schoolers. That's not to say I dislike the series' on going trope, but that I felt it was a nice break from it.
I preferred Eternal Punishment because more Maya and Nyarly. It's really intense. Innocent Sin was more mysterious, but I love how EP comes full circle and Nyarlathotep is just such a fun antagonist.

Inb4 Hibiki says they're both shit
They are just the same game split in two.
IS has the benefit of feeling the most standalone though.
I actually wasn't going to comment on this but I feel the need to fulfill expectations.

They're both shit.

Ulala's pretty cool though.
Don't you fight Hitler in part 2 of persona 2
That's part 1.