Unpopular Opinion? - Phansite Archive

Hibiki

Unpopular Opinion?

Okay I don't know how unpopular this might actually be but I shall drop it before I sleep anyway.

Persona 3 had the best cast of characters in the series (ignoring P2, because that is a can of worms I do not want to open right now).

The P5 cast I think are the most realistic as a group of friends, but in terms of character development and how they react to each other and the situation they're in, they're the best, and it helps that most of the cast didn't need a Social Link to make them feel complete.

Discuss or whatever, good night.

Hibiki

Yukari Takeba is good.

imtherealklib

This is an unpopular opinion?

Aki-Joker

I agree a lot with this. Also Stupei is alright.

Kirusu

Junpei is both the best detective in the series, and best boy

Kotone Shiomi

main cast? sure why not i can see that
side cast? god no

Kitagawa

I don't like any of the dateable females in P5, I think they are all pretty boring. It's not because I am super gay too, I am actually alright with ladies but none of them are interesting enough for me to consider...

Maybe Futaba but at the same time it's a bit too awkward for me to smash her and I would rather just sit there, alone, and pine for Yusuke.

Reminds me much of what I do irl, honestly.

Hibiki

Remember when Ultimate Personas were unlocked via story and not Social Links cuz I do and bitch motherfucker bring that back.

Mako-chan

@Hibiki

Yes. Fully agree. P3 has the best characters, and Yukari is good. I agree with everything you said about P3 and P5. Yes.

Pancake_Knight

I agree! Persona 3 is an amazing game! Brought me into the franchise, currently playing P4 rn and the characters are pretty good. However while P5 had the best gameplay by far, the characters seem kinda dumbed down for a mainstream audience, they also feel kinda rushed (looking at you Haru)

Spectrum

P3 is the only one I have seen all of so...

I think I have to agree? It's my favourite.

Hibiki

I will fight anyone who says Yukari isn't good

Hibiki

Also the P3 S.Links are still the most invested I've been with the side characters honestly

AdachiImouto

P4 is the worst main Persona game, IMHO. (I haven't played P1 so I cannot rate that one)

Picking on P4 a little more, I found Yosuke to be annoying and the worst Magician.

Revali_Fudo

-Not a big one, but I didn't mind Kenji in P3.

-I reeeeally don't like Nanako. I dislike most kid characters as is and I flat out hate the "cute" kid characters like Nanako or Bonnie from Pokemon. *Censored* really gets on my nerves.