Welcome to Phansite archive (beta)
You'll find here all archived threads from the Phansite forum.
Plot Swapping
Take a moment to think about what it would be like if you took the cast of one Persona game, and dropped them into the plot and world of a completely different Persona game.

For example...
Imagine the Persona 4 cast having to deal with the Dark Hour and Tartarus.
I'd think this would be... entertaining.
The Scooby gang wouldn't stand a chance.

But you're right, that is a fun thing to think about.
The P5 crew would do okay in tarturus. Only because of Momentos.
I would Like to see Minatos gang as Phantom Thieves .
Mitsuru would fit a mask.

I can almost imagine Aigis trying to shoot the fox for "giving suspicious leaves, target must be eliminated." Also, I wanna see Koromaru's Shadow. I feel it would be an entertaining cutscene. I imagine it goes something like this:

KS: Woof, woof, bark.

Koro: Whine, whine

KS: WOOF, WOOF.

Koro; *Growl8

And thus commences the Koro boss fight.
P5 in P2 because I wanna see Haru pull a grenade launcher out on Hitler at point blank range.
The Scooby Gang in any other Persona game.

The Inaba Gang in Scooby Doo would actually work wonders
bumps because persona discussion
Phantom thrives in p4. Because we can see Morgana get bothered by his shadow.
Put the P1 cast in the P5's cast place. There's already some nice parallels that can be drawn between some of the characters and how society views them. Plus I think it'd be pretty awesome to see how the P1 cast would awaken to their rebellious spirits and the P5 cast deal with demons suddenly invading. I feel like the P5 cast would have a harder time just because they weren't all friends before things started going down in their game like the P1 crew. Be interesting to see how they might form a group though.
P1 cast in P5's story is definitely something I wanna see now.